A Randomized Clinical Trial On Effectiveness Of Manual Therapy In Management Of Knee Osteoarthritis At Two Selected Teaching Hospitals In Zambia
Volume 4 - Issue 3, March 2020 Edition
[Download Full Paper]
Sporah Chisha, Margaret M. Mweshi, Brian Chanda Chiluba
Conventional therapy, Knee Osteoarthritis, Manual therapy, Physiotherapy.
Osteoarthritis which is a degenerative joint disease affecting the articular cartilage, bone and soft tissues around the joint is a highly prevalent condition worldwide with an incidence of 20.4% at the University Teaching Hospital and Levy Mwanawasa Teaching Hospital in Zambia. It has no known effective intervention due to its poorly understood pathogenesis. Combined interventions of Manual Therapy and Conventional Physiotherapy are significant in restoring function, quality of life, reducing disability, drug consumption and surgery in individuals with knee OA. This study evaluated the emerging optimistic evidence on the effectiveness of manual therapy, established the possible factors associated with it and assessed its impact on physical function and quality of life in patients with knee osteoarthritis. This study was a single-blinded RCT involving 6 male and 24 female participants with bilateral knee osteoarthritis aged between 30-85 years at University Teaching Hospital and Levy Mwanawasa Teaching Hospital. Participants were randomized using un-labelled opaque envelops to a conventional group (n=15) and intervention group (n=15). The conventional group received a treatment protocol of hot packs, Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation and exercise therapy, while those in the intervention group received the same protocol combined with manual therapy twice per week for 5 weeks giving 10 treatment sessions. Short Form 36 questionnaire (SF-36), Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), Six-minute walk test questionnaire (6-MWT) and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) were tools used for data collection before and after treatment. Data was entered in SPSS imported into Microsoft Excel and analyzed using STATA software version 13. Paired t-test mean values of group effect for VAS, 6-MWT, WOMAC and SF-36 Questionnaire were compared at week 0 and week 5. There was an improvement in all mean values; VAS (2.4), 6-MWT (195.75), WOMAC (51) and SF-36 (307.9) to 1.5, 276.3, 30 and 542.2 respectively. The difference between conventional and interventional groups was statistically significant for the WOMAC and SF-36 Questionnaire (p = 0.0102 and p = 0.0085). Differences were not significant for 6-MWT (p = 0.1678) and VAS (p = 0.2893). Adding manual therapy to conventional physiotherapy is more effective in reducing knee pain, improving walking distance, physical function and quality of life in patients with knee osteoarthritis. The effects of manual therapy on knee osteoarthritis were sustained up to 2 weeks after treatment.
 McAlindon, T. Bannuru, R. Sullivan, M. Arden, N. Berenbaum, F. Zeinstra, S. Underwood, M. â€œOARSI Guidelines for the nonsurgical management of knee osteoarthritis, Osteoarthritis and Cartilageâ€. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage Journal, XXII, pp. 363-388, 2014.
 Abbott, J. Robertson, M. Chapple, C. â€œManual therapy, exercise therapy or both as additional to usual care for OA of the hip or kneeâ€. Osteoarthritis and cartilage Journal, v21, pp.525-534, 2013.
 Ahmad, A. and Daud, M. â€œA comparative study between joint mobilization and conventional physiotherapy in knee osteoarthritisâ€. International Journal of Physiotherapy, Vol 3(2), pp. 159-162, 2016.
 Akinpelu, A. Alonge, T. Adekania, B. and Odole, A. â€œPrevalence and pattern of symptomatic knee osteoarthritis in Nigeriaâ€. The Internal Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 1-7, available at http://ijahsp.nova.edu, 2009.
 Ali, S. Ahmed, I. and Khan, M. â€œComparing the effects of manual therapy versus electrophysical agents in the management of knee osteoarthritisâ€. Pakistan journal of pharmaceutical sciences, Vol. 27, No. 4, pp.1103-1106, 2014.
 llen, K. and Golightly, Y. â€œEpidemiology of osteoarthritis: state of the evidenceâ€. Journal of Curr Opin Rheumatol, Vol. 27, pp. 276â€“283, 2015.
 Alrushud, A. El-Sobkey, S. Hafez, A. Al-Ahaideb, A. â€œImpact of knee osteoarthritis on the quality of life among Saudi elders: A comparative studyâ€. Saudi Journal of Sports Medicine, Vol. 13, Issue. 1, pp.10-16, 2013.
 Anwer, S. Ahmad, A. Zafar, H. and Brismee, J. â€œEffects of orthopaedic manual therapy in knee osteoarthritis: A systematic review and meta-analysisâ€. Physiotherapy Journal Vol.104, pp. 264-276, 2018.
 Arshad, N. Ijaz Gondal, M. Qamar, M. Basharat, A. â€œManual therapy can be a potential therapy in knee osteoarthritisâ€. Saudi Journal of Sports Medicine, Vol. 18 pp. 18â€‘2, 2018.
 Ateef, M. Kulandaivelan, S. Tahseen, S. â€œTestâ€“ retest reliability and correlates of 6-minute walk test in patients with primary osteoarthritis of kneesâ€. Indian Journal of Rheumatology, Vol.11 pp.192-196, 2016.
 Barber, R. Fullman, N. Sorensen, R. Bollyky, T. â€œHealthcare access and quality index based on mortality from amenable to personal health care in 195 countries and territories, 1990-2015: A novel analysis from the global burden of disease study 2015â€. The Lancet, Vol. 390, pp 231-266, 2017.
 Bernhardsson, S. Kredo, T. Machingaidze, S. Young, T. â€œAdvancing evidence-based practice in physical therapy settings: multinational perspectives on implementation strategies and interventionsâ€. Journal of Physical Therapy, Vol. 97, pp. 51-60, 2017.
 Bija, M. Luma, H. Temfack, E. Gueleko, E. Kemta, F. and Ngandeu, M. â€œPatterns of knee osteoarthritis in a hospital setting in sub-Saharan Africaâ€. Journal of Clinical Rheumatology, Vol.14, pp. 2702-3, 2014.
 Bohannon, R. Bubela, D. Magasi, S. McCreath, H. â€œComparison of walking performance over the first 2 minutes and the full 6 minutes of the six- minute Walk Testâ€. Journal of BMC Research Notes, Vol. 7, pp. 269, 2014.
 Chen, B. Zhan, H. Marszalek, J. â€œManual therapy for knee osteoarthritis: A systematic review and meta-analysisâ€. Osteoarthritis and cartilage journal, Vol. 26, pp. 60-474, 2018.
 Chu Buh, F. Vukugah, A. Ghyslaine, B. Atemkeng, T. and Krishna, N. â€œConventional Physiotherapy and Additional Krishnaâ€™s Kinetikinetic Manual Therapy (KKMT) For Knee Osteoarthritis Rehabilitation: A Comparative studyâ€ IJARP, Vol. 2, Issue. 1, pp.54-58, January 2018.
 Ciolac, E. Silva, J. Greve, J. â€œEffects of resistance training in older women with knee osteoarthritis and total knee arthroplastyâ€. Journal of Clinics, Vol. 70, pp. 7â€“13, 2015.
 Conley, S. Feder, S. Redeker, N. â€œThe relationship between pain, fatigue, depression and functional performance in stable heart failureâ€. Journal of Heart and Lung, Vol. 44, pp. 107â€“112, 2015.
 Cross, M. Smith, E. Holy, D. Noite, S. â€œThe global burden of hip and knee osteoarthritis: Estimates from the global of disease 2010 studyâ€. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, Vol 73, pp. 1323-1330, 2014.
 Crossley, K. Stefanik, J. Selfe, J. â€œPatellofemoral pain consensus statement from the 4th International Patellofemoral Pain Research Retreat, Manchester. Part 1: Terminology, definitions, clinical examination, natural history, patellofemoral osteoarthritis and patient reported outcome measures. Journal of Sports Medicine, Vol. 50, pp. 839-843, 2016.
 Correia de Faria SantarÃ©m, G. de Cleva, R. Santo, M. â€œCorrelation between Body Composition and Walking Capacity in Severe Obesityâ€. Journal of pone, Vol. 10, pp. 1-10, 2015.
 Fernandes, L. Hagen, K. Bijlsma, J. Andreassen, O. Christensen, P. â€œEULAR recommendations for the non-pharmacological core management of hip and knee osteoarthritisâ€. Annals of the rheumatic diseases. Vol. 72, pp.1125â€“35, 2013.
 Fitzgerald, G. Fritz, J. Childs, J. â€œExercises, manual therapy and use of booster sessions in physical therapy for knee OAâ€. Journal of Osteoarthritis and cartilage, Vol. 24, pp.1340-1349, 2016.
 Hame, S. and Alexander, R. â€œKnee osteoarthritis in womenâ€. Journal of Curr Rev Musculoskeletal Medicine, Vol. 6, pp. 182â€“187, 2013.
 Hameed, R. Waqas, M. Akhtar, F. Joseph, R. Niazi, A. Mahmood, A. â€œEffect of Manual Therapy on Knee Osteoarthritis (OA) Pain, A Randomized Control Trialâ€. International Journal of Research Studies in Medical and Health Sciences, Vol. 2, Issue. 4, pp. 19-22, 2017.
 Ilori, T. Ladipo, M. Ogunbode, A. and Obimakinde, A. â€œKnee osteoarthritis and perceived social support amongst patients in a family medicine clinicâ€. Journal of South African Family Practice, Vol. 58, pp. 202-206, 2016.
 Kaur, R. Ghosh, A. and Singh, A. â€œPrevalence of knee osteoarthritis and its determinants in 30-60 years old women of Gurdaspur, Punjabâ€. International Journal of Medical Science and Public Health, Vol. 7, pp. 825-30, 2018.
 Kawano, M. AraÃºjo, I. Castro, M. Matos, M. â€œAssessment of quality of life in patients with knee osteoarthritisâ€. Journal of Acta Ortop Bras, Vol. 23, pp, 307-10, 2015.
 Kellgren, J. and Lawrence, J. â€œRadiological assessment of osteoarthrosisâ€. Annals of Rheumatic Diseases, Vol. 16, pp. 494-502, 1997.
 Kiran, A. Ijaz, M. Qamar, M. and Basharat, A. â€œComparison of Efficacy of Mulliganâ€™s Mobilization with Movement with Maitland Mobilization along with Conventional Therapy in the Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Clinical Trialâ€. Libyan Int Med Univ Journal, Vol. 3, pp. 26-30, available at http://www.journal.limu.edu.ly, April 2018.
 Lupenga, J. Namwila, N. Munalula-Nkandu, E. Chiluba, B. â€œEvaluating Evidence Based Practice of Physiotherapists and The Quality of Physiotherapy Services in Selected Health Facilities of Lusaka, Zambiaâ€. Indonesian Journal of Disability Studies (IJDS), Vol. 6, pp. 133-142, 2019.
 Mahamed, A. Sivachidambaram, K. and Shaziya, T. â€œTestâ€“retest reliability and correlates of 6-minute walk test in patients with primary osteoarthritis of kneesâ€. Vol. 11 Issue. 4, pp. 192-196, 2016.
 McAlindon, T. Bannuru, R. Sullivan, M. â€œOsteoarthritis Research Society International guidelines for the non-surgical management of knee OAâ€. Journal of Osteoarthritis and cartilage, Vol. 22, pp. 363-388, 2014.
 Middelkoop, V. Bennel, L. Callaghan, J. â€œInternational patellofemoral osteoarthritis consortium: Consensus statement on diagnosis, burden, outcome measures, prognosis, risk factors and treatment. Journal of Seminars in Arthritis, Vol. 47, pp. 666-675, 2018.
 Mobasheri, A. â€œThe Future of Osteoarthritis Therapeutics: Targeted Pharmacological Therapyâ€. Journal of Curr Rheumatol Rep, Vol. 15, pp. 364, 2013.
 Mulla, Y. Munthali, J. Makasa, E. and Kayumba, K. â€œJoint replacement in Zambia: a review of Hip & Knee Replacement surgery done at the Zambian-Italian Orthopaedic Hospitalâ€. Medical Journal of Zambia, Vol. 37, No. 3, pp. 153-159, 2010.
 Palazzo, C. Nguyen, C. Lefevre-Colau, M. Rannou, F. and Poiraudeau, S. â€œRisk factors and burden of osteoarthritisâ€. Annals of physical and rehabilitation medicine, Vol. 59, pp. 134-138, 2016.
 Polat, C. DoÄŸan, A. Ã–zcan, D. â€œThe Effectiveness of Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation in Knee Osteoarthritis with Neuropathic Pain Component: A Randomized Controlled Studyâ€. Turk Journal of Osteoporos, Vol. 23, pp. 47-51, 2017.
 Postler, A. Ramos, A. Goronzy, J. GÃ¼nther, K. Lange, T. Schmitt, J. â€œPrevalence and treatment of hip and knee osteoarthritis in people aged 60 years or older in Germany: an analysis based on health insurance claims dataâ€. Journal of Clinical Interventions in Aging, Vol; 13 p: 2339â€“2349, 2018.
 Rhon, D. Deyle, G. Gill, N. and Rendeiro, D. â€œManual physical therapy and perturbation exercises in knee osteoarthritisâ€. Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy vol. 21 no.4, 2013.
 Salamh, P. Cook, C. Reiman, M. and Sheets, C. â€œTreatment effectiveness and fidelity of manual therapy to the knee: A systematic review and meta-analysisâ€. Journal of musculoskeletal care, Vol. 15, pp. 238-248, 2017.
 Sit, R. Chan, K. Zou, D. Chan, C. Yip, B. Zhang, D. Chan, Y. â€œClinic-Based Patellar Mobilization Therapy for Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Clinical Trialâ€. Journal of Annals and Family Medicine, Vol. 16, pp. 521-529, 2014.
 Sowers, M. and Karvonen-Gutierrez, C. â€œThe evolving role of obesity in knee osteoarthritisâ€. Journal of Curr Opin Rheumatol, Vol. 22, pp. 533â€“7, 2010.
 Turkiewicz, A. Petersson, F. Bjork, J. Hawker, G. and Daulberg, E. â€œCurrent and future impact of osteoarthritis on health care: A population- based study with projections to year 2032â€. Journal of Osteoarthritis and cartilage, Vol. 22, pp. 1826-1832, 2014.
 Usenbo, A. Kramer, V. Young, T. and Musekiwa, A. â€œPrevalence of Arthritis in Africa: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysisâ€. Journal of pone, Vol 10, pp. 1-19, 2015.
 Vos, T. Abajobir, A. Abate, K. Abbafati, C. Abbas, K. â€œGlobal, regional and national incidence, prevalence and years lived with disability for 328 diseases and injury for 195 countries 1990-2016: A systematic analysis for the global burden of disease study 2016â€. The Lancet, Vol. 390, pp. 1211-1259, 2016.
 Yusuf, E. â€œMetabolic factors in osteoarthritis: obese people do not walk on their handsâ€. Journal of Arthritis Res Ther, Vol. 14, pp.123, 2012.
 Yusuf, E. â€œPharmacologic and Non-Pharmacologic Treatment of Osteoarthritisâ€. Journal of Current Treatment Options in Rheum, Vol. 2, pp. 111â€“125, 2016.
 Zeng, C. Li, H. Yang, T. â€œElectrical stimulation for pain relief in knee osteoarthritis: systematic review and network meta-analysisâ€. Journal of osteoarthritis and cartilage, Vol. 23, pp.189-202, 2014.
 Zakir, A. Ahmed, S. Aziz, S. â€œEffectiveness of manual therapy versus exercise therapy for the management of knee osteoarthritis in Karachi Pakistanâ€. International Journal of Physiotherapy, Vol. 3, pp. 86-93, 2016.
 Rodrigues da Silva, J. de Rezende, M. Spada, T. Francisco, L. â€œEducational program promoting regular physical exercise improves functional capacity and daily living physical activity in subjects with knee osteoarthritisâ€. Journal of BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, Vol. 18, pp. 546, 2017.
 OuÃ©draogo, D. ZabsonrÃ©, J. Kenagnon, A. KaborÃ©, F. â€œQuality of Life of Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis with Questionnaire OAKHQOL (OsteoArthritis of Knee Hip Quality of Life) in Rheumatology Consultation in Burkina Faso (West Africa)â€. Open Journal of Rheumatology and Autoimmune Diseases, Vol. 4, pp. 219-225, 2014.
 Courtney, C. Steffen, A. FernÃ¡ndez-de-las-peÃ±as, C. Kim, J. Chmell, S. â€œJoint Mobilization Enhances Mechanisms of Conditioned Pain Modulation in Individuals with Osteoarthritis of the Kneeâ€. Journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy, Vol. 46, No. 3, pp. 168-176, 2016.
 Zhang, W. Ouyang, H. Dass, C. and Xu, J. â€œCurrent research on pharmacologic and regenerative therapies for osteoarthritisâ€. Journal of Bone Research, Vol. 4, pp. 15040, 2016.
 Murray, C. Vos, T. Lozano, R. Naghavi, M. Flaxman, A. â€œDisability adjusted life years (DALYs) for 291 diseases and injuries in 21 regions, 1990-2010: A systematic analysis for the global burden of disease study 2010â€. The Lancet, Vol. 380, pp. 2197-2223, 2012.